Wednesday, October 7, 2015

Climate Change and the New Wine Regions

There is no doubt that global temperatures have risen over their averages in the 1940-1980 period.  I offer no explanation for this, no recommendations and no predictions as to future (I’m a wine importer, not a politician or scientist).  But this increase in temperature has had a profound impact on the wine world.


What has been discussed is the impact on well recognized wine regions.  Burgundy, for example has far fewer years where it struggles to attain sufficient ripeness.  The Southern Rhone wines are riper, fruitier and more alcoholic than ever before.

What has not received much discussion is that these higher temperatures have pushed certain regions from being borderline in terms of their ability to produce wines of sufficient ripeness to allowing them to consistently produce wines with optimal ripeness.  
Burgundy’s last washout vintage was probably 1997. Although Jadot killed it but in general that is the last complete disaster.  

Some of these newer regions have always had good terroir.  Now they are making excellent wines and, because they are less well known because of their historical struggles, offer incredible values as compared to more well established regions.  

Irancy
Irancy has, near chablis in the northern tip of Burgundy, has always had good terroir but struggled with ripeness.  The wines were often green except in very hot years.  Now, they are consistently producing delicious wines with wonderful minerality and a touch of rusticity.

Germany - Franken and Baden
While parts of Baden were able to make good red wine, they are now home to several world class wineries including Enderle & Moll and Mobitz.  What is perhaps more surprising is further north, Franken is producing truly stunning wines.  Sebastien Fuerst has led the way with his bottlings from the great Centgrafenberg and Hundsruck vineyards.  His friend and neighbor Christoff Walter is now making stunning Grand Cru quality wines for a fraction of the cost of their brethren in Burgundy.  One grower told me that his father used to pick his grapes at 75 oechsle (a measure of ripeness) whereas he now picks at 95 oechsle.  

Dry German Riesling
Many areas of Germany have also had to adapt. It was too cool in the 80’s to make that much great dry Riesling but now in the Pfalz, Mosel, Rheinessen, Wurtttemberg and even Franken there is an ocean of great dry Riesling and that is because it takes warmer vintages to make great dry Riesling. It also has, in the Mosel, opened up attention to sites that are in the valleys near the more famous vineyards. These sites did not get enough sun but now they do. Places like Veldenz, Wittlich and Muhlheim are making some of the Mosel’s best dry wines now. 20 years ago you did not want to go near these sites.

Conclusion
I believe that ultimately, this represents a fundamental shift for the wine world.  Importers and consumers need to take notice of these changes and start to experiment with new regions that offer significant buying opportunities.  As an importer, I’m putting my money where my mouth is, traveling to these regions ( on my own dime) and offering these wines to my clients.  

2 comments:

  1. I'm glad to see you talk about this, Lyle - it's really important to all of us in the wine ecosystem. I particularly like your focus on previously under-appreciated regions which are now representing good value.

    As a native-born Brit, albeit expatriate for many years, I'm also fascinated by the growth in the English wine industry. English wine didn't exist in any real sense when I moved away in 1990. 25 years later, there's a huge amount of high-quality wine being produced.

    My current home - California - is another data point, as is the entire west coast. It seems to me that, as California, Oregon and Washington get warmer, the grape varieties which are now emblematic of those regions will have to change. I imagine that the sweet spot for Pinot Noir will move from Oregon, maybe even as far as British Columbia. The Okanagan Valley in BC produces pleasant Alsatian-style wines - maybe high-quality Riesling and Sauvignon Blanc might be grown there in addition to Pinot Noir.

    My biggest concern is California and, in particular, Napa and Sonoma. The ripeness of Napa Cabernets is increasingly overwhelming - huge, rich wines with sky-high alcohol. There's no room, it seems to me, for riper grapes in Napa and Sonoma. Further south, the Central Coast and Paso Robles are already specializing in Rhone-style wines, and that's working really well. Syrah and Chateauneuf-du-Pape-style wines are really good.

    Pete

    ReplyDelete
  2. Peter.

    Thanks for the comment. Ive always thought CA should be our N. and S. Rhone.

    ReplyDelete